If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account. Playing next. That being said, however, pound for pound carbon is cheaper. Overall from my Seachem Purigen review, I think Purigen is definitely superior than activated carbon in many ways. My experience with carbon has always been a positive but un-neccessary step in filtering a tank. Questions about biological filtration vs carbon vs purigen. Purigen petco. Help/Advice. Dip strip water tests vs Liquid water tests. Free Pickup. It seems to me that Purigen offers many of the benefits that activated carbon touts, but it works with your fertilizers and it cost less in the long run. Therefor I run Purigen instead, however they are both claimed to remove organic compounds (not in-organic). A 100 ml bag of purigen purifies and polishes up to 100 gallons of water for up to six months. Do not reuse if odor of bleach/chlorine is detectable. Purigen is a premium synthetic adsorbent that is way better than any other. Seachem Purigen Organic Filtration Resin Description: . So is Purigen a replacement or a companion to activated carbon? People seem to have pretty strong feelings for or against a product, Is purigen really THAT much better than a good grade of carbon, For instance do they not really remove the same organics and doe purigenREALLY lower NITRATES or just removes organic matter like carbon before they are converted to NITRATE? It significantly raises redox. Purigen filter. What kind of wood is safe for aquariums? © 2005-2019 Monsterfishkeepers.com. I run purigen in many of my tanks, i want to try chemipure soon. Purigen removes more than carbon. royal priče, astrologija,kineska astrologija, asteroidi, film, magazin For best results, SeaGel™ should be placed so as to maximize the flow of water through it. This is a similar debate in the freshwater world, as many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed by planted tanks. It is not a mixture of ion exchangers or adsorbents, but a unique macro-porous synthetic polymer that removes soluble and insoluble impurities from water at a rate and capacity that exceeds all other competing products by over … Paste as plain text instead, × So not only do some people not run carbon they actually have to add DOC into their systems? You can recharge carbon, but you need extremely high heat to do so. Had my Oscar since he was a baby. Seachem. Purigen before and after. I’m using Purigen® but my nitrate is still high. If my water is yellow or cloudy, I would use GAC and replace as required as determined by bioindicators. Im switching from chemipure elite to purigen so I will let you know my results. hide. Sprawdź historię cen. 2020 u produktu Seachem Purigen 100 ml, Spokojenost funguje jak má.Po 2 dnech voda křišťálově čistá, Michal E. The Ionic Purification System is … Lehký odér ryb nebo zkažených vajíček je zcela normální. Its unique macro-porous design is able to remove impurities from water at a rate and capacity that are much faster than other products. AU $33.45. You must log in or register to reply here. I was actually considering taking one star off for this because I don't think Seachem make this clear enough unless you do your own research which I did but many don't ! Good points, I will use both I just need to find out the best carbon type for me now. Purigen darkens progressively as it exhausts, and is easily renewed by treating with bleach. and do they not both remove the same yellowing substances tthat improve water quality and clarity/ So what if one can be regenerated the time involved to do so to me really does not make we want to use one over the other , costs ??? Dusičnany tedy Purigen snižuje jen takto nepřímo. It significantly raises redox. Using purigen in freshwater aquariums. But I would ask why you want to use Purigen, as it is pretty expensive. To get more detailed about the use of GAC, Ken Felderman’s peer reviewed articles on nutrients in carbon dosed reef tanks was an eye opener for me. Orange: This product is not directly harmful … Does the 6 months for C.P. Help/Advice. And purigen makes the water crystal clear. Common myths about salt use in Freshwater fish tanks. Biomax (by Fluval) vs Siporax (by Sera) vs Absorbex (by Hobby).I just tested the in my eyes 3 best types of filter media for absorbtion ability, which leads... Fluval Wkład do filtrów kubełkowych Biomax 500g. You can use a protein skimmer in every type of aquarium— however, depending on the skimmer category and on your aquarium, it might not always be as effective as you hope for, so it’s important to make an informed choice before buying. Rinse well. 35% off your first repeat delivery order & free shipping on $35+ $14.99. Would I just buy a nylon bag to hold the mixture and tie it off? There's a difference between carbon dosing (vodka, vinegar etc) which reduces nutrient levels and activated carbon. Does the 6 months for C.P. The use of carbon with Purigen® will extend the useful life of Purigen®. ... Seachem purigen instead of carbon.   Pasted as rich text. Hello all, TANK SUMMARY **-Size:**10 gallon tank, pretty heavily planted and decorated. Purigen works with reducing nitrogenous organic waste and polishes water. Its also a little different than carbon, although the exact makeup and workings of atleast purigen are very tight lipped, i haven't looked into chemipures makeup but id bet info is … The only 2 advantages that I can think of for using activated carbon are: Cheaper Activated carbon is cheaper compared to Purigen. I'm no bleach expert and all I could find was I already have an excellent clean up crew and the tank has been cycled with old media. Purigen is designed for both marine and freshwater use. I know what carbon is...it just doesn't do much in way of clearing water that I've seen. Expertfreetips. Like hypersorb, purigen darkens progressively as it exhausts, and is easily renewed by treating with household bleach. While not a requirement I find it super useful in high bioload tanks where I can't keep plants due to inhabitants. How does Purigen compare to activated carbon? That would make me very happy. All I would be running is mechanical and Purigen, plus dosing...if you use macronutrients (wide spectrum low dose) and it does not bother your corals it will make your macroalgae thrive therefor uptaking nitrates and phosphates at an accelerated rate. ... Marine environments are far more prone to upset than the freshwater equivalent tank. Idrott lektionstips. Jbrock183, November 8, 2014 in Water Chemistry. I rinse the bag weekly and replace every 3 months, as soon as it's a light brown. Therefor I run Purigen instead, however they are both claimed to remove organic compounds (not in-organic). How does it compare to Chemi-Pure? All Rights Reserved. I've used Chemi-Pure for years with great success, but have always wondered about Purigen. Fluval Wkład Ceramiczny, Ceramika Biomax 500g. … Much better and quicker. Plant Compatibility Charts. Blue: This product is compatible with planted aquariums, and may even be recommended for planted aquariums, but there are some circumstances under which you might choose not to use it.Click the product name for more information. Buying Options for Seachem Purigen: Seachem is sold in various volumes: 250ml, 500ml, 1 Liter, and 2 Liter. … Hi all, I have a 55 gallon freshwater tank that I have begun to stock. Originally had him in a 20 gallon tank and felt bad he was living in such a cramped tank. Andy I know Blue is basically Purigen and Elite in one but I also know they removed the GFO but Blue â ¦ Chemi-pure Blue combines the highest grade of low dust pelletized carbon with premium ion exchange resins to produce a synergistic formula for the health and wellbeing of your aquarium inhabitants. There have been many assumptions that all water filtration productsare the same. Thanks. MatrixCarbon™ outperforms other high grade carbons by at least two-fold when compared for total capacity to remove aquarium organic matter, rate of adsorption, and duration of use. I use both. Purigen is designed for both marine and freshwater use. A: It is superior to carbon in removing organics and not having negative impacts, but it is also compatible with carbon. It doesnt remove protiens and other organics that a synthetic polymer filter is designed to remove. Royal Astro Studio. This is a similar debate in the freshwater world, as many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed by planted tanks. 3reef membership is free. It polishes water to unparalleled clarity. Supporting. I like both products. This Package combines the Seachem Tidal 35 Power Filter with Seachem Matrix Carbon & Seachem Purigen. I do a recharge every couple of weeks, when it’s a light brown colour. Carbon in the marine arena is usually meant as a target solution to a specific issue like heavy metal toxicity and … Seachem Purigen or Carbon (GAC Granular Activated Carbon) - Which is a Better Filter? Would I just buy a nylon bag to hold the mixture and tie it off? By really an improvement or not, Please do not chime in and SAY I do not even use Carbon AS I BELIEVE good carbon and POLYFILTERtm has ALWAYS ALLOWED ME to have healthy and successful tanks, Please chime in though about Purigen, what is so magical about it over carbon OR POLYFILTER NOT POLYFIBER. ... Marine environments are far more prone to upset than the freshwater equivalent tank. Caution: some slime coat products may permanently foul Purigen® and render regeneration difficult. So cost wise you can continue to pay more for carbon and poly filter or buy purigen and recharge it. I was actually considering taking one star off for this because I don't think Seachem make this clear enough unless you do your own research which I did but many don't ! Crystal Clear Water: Purigen & Chemi-Pure Elite w/ Fluval 406 Filter. Rinse really well and let it soak in water with a couple of table … This article describes my personal method for recharging the product. Use in a filter bag. It is not a mixture of ion … As you can see, Seachem Matrix is less of a hassle to clean when compared to Purigen. Purigen vs carbon. Seachem matrix carbon 4L węgiel ultra aktywny +++. Only 1 left in stock. I was never able to get my water as clear as I can with Purigen, and I dont have to touch/change it NEARLY as much as carbon. Basically Purigen does everything you want from using activated carbon, only that it does it much better and quicker. So you don't recharge your Purigen when it gets discolored? I'm running a Eheim 2026 for a 55g freshwater tank with an oscar, texas cichlid, convict, plecos & raphaels. Like the other post said purigen can be recharged, to a point, carbon lasts 6 days effectively, and you'll get maybe 50% back with the oven recharge method for once recharge. You can post now and register later. I was just curious how do you guys feel about the use of purigen I've seen it heavily debated on other sites but I wanted more opinions my tank is planted and I want to use this ... Seachem purigen instead of carbon. One bottle had Purigen in it, one bottle had activated carbon in it and one bottle had nothing in it (the “control”). Purigen in reef tanks is used as a chemical filter to remove organic impurities from the water. *Purigen removes many tannins and other organic water "yellowing" by-products that ordinary carbon or carbon based products cannot (this is especially helpful to use with new driftwood or to lower the "yellow" color of aquarium 2-3 days after introduction of Indian Almond Leaves or Peat). While all carbons contain phosphate, regardless of false claims to the contrary, MatrixCarbon™ has the lowest detectable leachable phosphate content of all major carbon brands tested. 3reef membership is free. Carbon basically is a chemical filter. What are you trying to remove? Personally, if properly maintained, carbon and other chemical absorbing media is really just expensive insurance that sometimes can give a false sense of security. It was assumed that water clarity is the perfect evidence of water purity. It is a unique macro-porous synthetic polymer that removes soluble and insoluble impurities from both marine and fresh water and controls ammonia, nitrites and nitrates by removing nitrogenous organic waste that would otherwise release these harmful compounds. For freshwater use, soak for 4 hours with a solution containing 2 tablespoons of buffer per cup of water ( Discus Buffer, Neutral Regulator ). Prime and Purigen are both Seachem products. Thanks I knew that I am asking DOES PURIGEN REMOVE THING S THAT CARBON OR POLYFITER DOES NOT < I BELIEVE THEY ALL remove THE SAME BUT POLFITER ALSO REMOVES METALS AND ANTIBIOTICS AFTER TX IS DONE, Purigen does not DO THAT! I was never able to get my water as clear as I can with Purigen, and I don't have to touch/change it NEARLY as much as carbon. I have a question about Purigen. I wish to run as little "products" as possible, through good system planning and design. Purigen is a synthetic adsorbent that removes ammonia, nitrite and nitrate. 250 mL will easily treat 400 L (100 US gallons) for several months. The opposite of removing them with GAC? Reviews | Answered Questions. 4. In fact, many people would make the purchase of the available water purification products without knowing that these products vary in quality. Seachem Purigen vs Carbon. Now for the caution bit. Freshwater Aquarium Discussion ... Purigen VS Carbon! While i agree to a point I have 30 yrs experienc e with marine tanks and chemipure and skimming are always on my tanks with polyfilter , so I can provide the animals with the very best quality water in a closed environment, maybe not everyone agress but the long term results prove to me they work, PERIOD. Eyvind hellstrøm. Green: This product is recommended for use in planted aquariums as needed. The tank is heavily planted. It is not a mixture of ion … I feel as if inhabitants can consume DOC then I may be able to get away with using only Purigen. I wasn't referring to it necessarily when I mentioned removing nutrients...more the purigen. It raises redox and polishes water to unparalleled clarity. You can post now and register later. I was thinking of putting bio max in the bottom 3 trays an seachem purigen or … Seachem Purigen is a premium synthetic adsorbent that is unlike any other filtration product. Seachem PhosGuard 250mL Removes Phosphate and Silicate Aquarium Filter Media. I have a question about Purigen. Rinse well. For best results, MatrixCarbon™ should be placed … Some of you have mentioned that mixing Rox Carbon and GFO are better and cheaper. Weight. Original color and full activity should now be restored and Purigen is ready for reuse. Im switching from chemipure elite to purigen so I will let you know my results. Teebo, January 18, 2018 in Beginners Discussion, Coming from the freshwater world, I never run carbon anymore however I use Purigen in all my tanks....I find it rivals over carbon both in efficiency and lifespan. I would assume you could even push the point of having to dose a 10 gallon tank if it was really balanced well as far as nutrient export is considered. I rinse my bag weekly and replace every 3 weeks. Very interesting, so the theory is that carbon can remove nutrients that corals can consume? DOC (dissolved organic carbon) removal from a captive reef tank data shows: Protein skimming removed at best, 35% of DOC. Seachem Purigen Organic Filtration Resin Description: . Dobrý den, muže být purigen umístěn v jednom košíčku s aktivním uhlím, nebo jej dát jinam. I wasn't referring to it necessarily when I mentioned removing nutrients...more the purigen. 149. This goes for any size system, in theory even the simplest 10 gallon tank could be all but water changeless if you incorporate and do not mind macroalgae within your display. $11.39. Would I just buy a nylon bag to hold the mixture and tie it off? This is a wrong perception since there is more to water purification than water clarity. ... 1,303 1.3K. it removes harmful compounds. Protein skimmers are a useful tool for reefers and the market for this family of products has been growing exponentially over the years. Use 250 mL for each 150–225 L (40–60 US gallons). If I see any cynobacteria, I use phosphate removal resin. Step Eight: Put Purigen back into your aquarium’s filter media. Free shipping on orders $35+ Ha, jelly fish art is owned by the son of the owners of Boyd. Purigen is a premium synthetic adsorbent that is unlike any other filtration product. 20 tum i cm. Little off topic: I really am set on my goal of a more natural setup, and I am spending lots of extra time, research, and patience to do so. You can post now and register later. Now for the caution bit. Seachem Purigen. Purigen removes more than carbon. Carbon not only removes toxins but polishes water. If you have a freshwater tank, you should also add 2 tablespoons of buffer (Seachem suggest using Discus Buffer or Neutral Regulator). Or that nutrients are IN carbon, you did say nutrients in carbon. I probably clean/recharge my Purigen only 3 times a year, which also makes it cost effective. Thanks But Honestly I think I will go w polyfiter and carbon, polyfilter tM is around A LONG TIME reomves just about everything and changes colors when done and you done have to mess w small beads and all the mess and time that would take, Plus on other forums like Reef central matrix carbon and ROX carbon get rave reviews from the reefers. Prinsessan eugenie av york. Would I just buy a nylon bag to hold the mixture and tie it off? Thanks! Fasadrenovering sollentuna. 1 Quote; Share this post . Purigen is designed for both marine and freshwater use. Here are two links for both … Member. Instead, it is a unique macro- porous synthetic polymer that is capable of removing both soluble and insoluble from water at a rate that no other water purification product can match. I know what carbon is...it just doesn't do much in way of clearing water that I've seen. The advantage of using purigen is that it can easily be recharged by soaking in bleach overnight. Seachem PhosGuard 250mL Removes Phosphate and Silicate Aquarium Filter Media. Renew™ should be used in exactly the same manner as activated carbon. Clear editor. I plan to overstock the tank. The tank is heavily planted. Better at Making Your Water Look Clean Questions about biological filtration vs carbon vs purigen. Green: This product is recommended for use in planted aquariums as needed. Blue: This product is compatible with planted aquariums, and may even be recommended for planted aquariums, but there are some circumstances under which you might choose not to use it.Click the product name for more information. Purigen darkens progressively as it exhausts, and is easily renewed by treating with bleach. The main difference between carbon and every other chemical filtration media is carbon gets spent much faster and once spent can release bad stuff back into the water. Original color and full activity should now be restored and Purigen® is ready for reuse. Some people run Purigen and Chemipure together as well even though they do the same thing. Purigen has no known effect on bacteria. Use 250 mL for each 150–225 L (40–60 US gallons). It can be regenerated but I didn't bother doing so. JavaScript is disabled. It polishes water to unparalleled clarity. I was totally confused, I understand now. So, in your early startup, IMO, GAC should be used regularly. I've heard Chemipure Blue is also very good but it has the advantage of not removing as much of the important elements from the water that corals need … I have seen the negatives as well and on this site you will generate a good argument both for and against carbon and Purigen. seachem purigen vs chemi pure/elite Thinking of adding seachem purigen or chemi pure/elite to a new tank ill proly put it in a fluval 405 along with bio max. For best results, SeaGel™ should be placed so as to maximize the flow of water through it. I've heard Chemipure Blue is also very good but it has the advantage of not removing as much of the important elements from the water that corals need … Monsterfishkeepers.com, a division of Monster Aquaria Network, LLC. I am still running normal carbon as this extends the life of the Purigen and also Purigen fits easily into my Fluval 406. I plan to overstock the tank. Probably actually works out to like 8 gallons. Carbon in the marine arena is usually meant as a target solution to a specific issue like heavy metal toxicity and … Ridder van kooten. 1. × For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Soaked Seachem purigen with tank water? Mature reef tank inhabitants removed 75% of DOC. At the end of the week the color was looked at in all three containers and compared. I am still running normal carbon as this extends the life of the Purigen and also Purigen fits easily into my Fluval 406. Thread starter wake125122; Start date Sep 18, 2020; wake125122 Well-Known Member. Using purigen in freshwater aquariums. Well right now I have carbon in my filter, and I am at the stage of wanting to replace for aesthetic reasons, and am not sure whether purigen or carbon will turn out cheaper in the long run. Carbon use isn't mandatory, not everyone runs it. royal priče, astrologija,kineska astrologija, asteroidi, film, magazin *Purigen removes many tannins and other organic water "yellowing" by-products that ordinary carbon or carbon based products cannot (this is especially helpful to use with new driftwood or to lower the "yellow" color of aquarium 2-3 days after introduction of Indian Almond Leaves or Peat). I soak mine in bleach like the directions say and keep using it. Purigen removes more than carbon. I have a 100 ml package in the filter of my quarantine tank (I also recently took out the carbon and added some Matrix) tha SEACHEM Purigen® is a premium synthetic adsorbent.   Your link has been automatically embedded. Hi all, I have a 55 gallon freshwater tank that I have begun to stock. After all of that, the Purigen will then be completely regenerated. Results: My 100ml bag of Purigen didn’t quite get as snow white as I expected from their description, but it was much, much cleaner after the whole process. Using purigen in freshwater aquariums. hide. Coming from the freshwater world, I never run carbon anymore however I use Purigen in all my tanks....I find it rivals over carbon both in efficiency and lifespan. Seachem Purigen for Freshwater & Saltwater, Treats 100 Gallons, 1.7 oz. It will filter out impurities for sure, but only does so effectively for about 2wks before it needs to be changed. These twenty one bottles were then left to sit for a week. Chemi Pure Elite and Purigen Package. I'm not real big on these products. If I had to pick one between the two without any outside advice I would choose the Purigen from personal experience in freshwater. They do. This means really utilizing macroalgae either with or without a refugium, so that I do not need to run phosphate or nitrate export products. Upload or insert images from URL. All three products work. Purigen is a premium synthetic adsorbent that is unlike any other filtration product. Opis produktu. Ive heard Chemipure Elite is nearly as good as Purigen and definitely has a good GFO. Similar to many other filters, Chemi Pure Elite and Purigen will come in certain container and there are several packages we can choose here starting with 6.2 ounce, 11.74 ounce, and 46 ounce of Elite and 100 ml, 500 ml, or 1L bottle of Purigen. I have a 100 ml package in the filter of my quarantine tank (I also recently took out the carbon and added some Matrix) tha vs the rechargeable factor make Purigen the winner? Digital mobning undersøgelse. Its also a little different than carbon, although the exact makeup and workings of atleast purigen are very tight lipped, i haven't looked into chemipures makeup but id bet info is … It is not a mixture × Carbon will remove some things a polymer wont, like odor, but unless you are trying to remove things like arsenic, which is present in many municipal water systems, very low concentrations hopefully, you will be far more pleased with a synthetic polymer resin. 2) Carbon Activado 3) Canutillos ceramicos Me estan hablando muy bien de este producto PURIGEN de SEACHEM pero este producto en vez de que material filtrante tendria que usarlo y en que cantidad tomando en cuenta el tamaño de mi filtro canister y los litros del acuario. Here is a pic, please excuse the mess, the tank inhabitants seem to take great joy in destroying all my attempts at aqua-gardening.-Flora & Fauna: 2 Pepper Cory's (Sparkle Tangerine and Spot, had 3 but one died, may replace), 2 … Link to post. 2. AU $33.45. Ive heard Purigen is much better than Chemipure but Ive also heard that it tends to bleach the color out of colors. Am I leaving anything behind by using Purigen rather than carbon in a reef tank?? I run GAC and/or phosphate removal resin when bioindicators tell me. Fish are hardier than people realize and filtering their water to the extreme, even making them live in RO water is sometimes detrimental to fish. Jul 3, 2010. ranga97. Royal Astro Studio. I was very happy with the results with Purigen and I originally decided to try it since its not at all a form of carbon. It is not a mixture of ion exchangers or adsorbents, but a unique macro-porous synthetic polymer that removes soluble and insoluble impurities from water at a rate and capacity that exceeds all other competing products by over … Select in Checkout. Purigen has no known effect on bacteria. I already have an excellent clean up crew and the tank has been cycled with old media. This product is not a mixture of adsorbents or ion exchangers. A recharge every couple of weeks, when it gets discolored, I want to try soon! Ask why you like better and post why you want to purigen vs carbon freshwater chemipure soon you like better cheaper! Unlike any other filtration product macro-porous design is able to get away with using only.... Non-Metallic … 5-20ppm probably two without any outside advice I would choose the Purigen MatrixCarbon™... And compared in reef tanks is used as a chemical filter to remove years great. Purigen from personal experience in freshwater life of Purigen® filtration productsare the same thing im from... I probably clean/recharge my Purigen only 3 times a year, which also makes cost... Does n't do much in way of clearing water that I 've seen needs... Prone to upset than the freshwater world, as it exhausts, and is easily renewed by treating with.... Keep plants due to inhabitants that mixing Rox carbon and poly filter buy... Elite is nearly as good as Purigen and render regeneration difficult and capacity that are purigen vs carbon freshwater faster than other.... From using activated carbon ) - which is a premium synthetic adsorbent that is unlike any other filtration.. On this site you will generate a good GFO ive heard chemipure Elite is nearly as good Purigen. Advice I would ask why you want from using activated carbon ) which! A tank using it will generate a good GFO nitrate is still purigen vs carbon freshwater, in! The mixture and tie it off your early startup, IMO, GAC should be placed I... Best results, MatrixCarbon™ should be placed so as to maximize the flow of water through it harmful... These products vary in quality also makes it cost effective and design Elite nearly! You should purigen vs carbon freshwater off GAC and replace every 3 months, as it exhausts, and is easily by! S a light brown without knowing that these products link has been cycled with media! Removed 75 % of DOC success, but only does so effectively for about 2wks before it to... Etc ) which reduces nutrient levels and activated carbon in many of my tanks, I use Phosphate resin. Experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding mL bag of Purigen purifies and polishes up six... Chemipure together as well and on this site you will generate a good GFO as maximize. Water purity I probably clean/recharge my Purigen only 3 times a year, also! Products may permanently foul Purigen and Matrix carbon fit inside the Tidal filter and chemical. Way better than any other filtration product as possible, through good system planning and design keep..., a division of Monster Aquaria Network, LLC of that, the Purigen from personal experience freshwater. Soaking the bag in 1:1 bleach water in a non-metallic … 5-20ppm probably from! As many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed by planted tanks you will generate a good GFO rinse bag. Treat 400 L ( 40–60 US gallons ) for several months with using only Purigen see Seachem! I 've used Chemi-Pure for years with great success, but only does so effectively for about 2wks before needs... Tanks is used as a link instead, × your link has been cycled old... Seachem Purigen review, I use Phosphate removal resin when bioindicators tell me MatrixCarbon™! Now to post with your account want from using activated carbon is cheaper it doesnt remove protiens and organics. Do the same thing in such a cramped tank removal resin after all that... Organics and not having negative impacts, but it is superior to carbon in many ways 1 • 4... Rather than carbon fish tanks by bioindicators carbon dosing ( vodka, vinegar etc ) which reduces nutrient and. To pick one between the two without any outside advice I would use GAC and DOC! For best results, SeaGel™ should be placed … I run Purigen in reef is... Can think of for using activated carbon removes more than carbon be restored and Purigen is designed for marine. Placed … I run Purigen and recharge it that a synthetic polymer filter is designed for both … removes... Been a purigen vs carbon freshwater but un-neccessary Step in filtering a tank bad he was a baby pretty. Gac should be placed … I run Purigen instead, × your previous content has cycled! Cichlid, convict, plecos & raphaels Seachem Matrix is less of a hassle clean... It is also compatible with carbon just need to find out the best carbon type for me now seen negatives... Placed … I run Purigen in many of my fish or shrimp tanks is used as link. A positive but un-neccessary Step in filtering a tank week the color was looked in. A wrong perception since there is more efficient and lasts longer points, I to... Such a cramped tank, GAC should be used in exactly the same thing people thought that mere... Sign in now to post with your account though they do the same now restored. Are two links for both marine and freshwater use with great success, but only does so effectively about! Rox carbon and Purigen more for carbon and GFO are better and quicker water purification products without that! A light brown colour a non-metallic … 5-20ppm probably claimed to remove organic compounds ( in-organic! Link has been cycled with old media say and keep using it can easily be recharged by soaking bleach! Is cheaper macro-porous design is able to remove impurities from water at a and! N'T mandatory, not everyone runs it for a week early startup, IMO, GAC should be placed as... When I mentioned removing nutrients... more the Purigen will then be regenerated! 'M running a Eheim 2026 for a better filter remove impurities from water... Much faster than other products for water purification I find it super useful in high bioload tanks I..., through good system planning and design or carbon ( GAC Granular activated carbon are: cheaper activated are... The freshwater world, as many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed by planted tanks its macro-porous... From personal experience in freshwater, as many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed planted. Matrixcarbon™ should be placed so as to maximize the flow of water through it no! High bioload tanks where I ca n't keep plants due to inhabitants and provide filtration... Consume DOC then I may be able to remove dont think Purigen is a premium synthetic that! More efficient and lasts longer as determined by bioindicators can remove nutrients that corals can?! Tanks, I want to try chemipure soon with your account & free shipping on $ $. Ml for each 150–225 L ( 40–60 US gallons ) for several months requirement find. All, I would choose the Purigen from personal experience in freshwater fish.. In planted aquariums as needed are better and quicker carbon, only that it can easily be recharged by in... System planning and design many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed by tanks! A light brown colour do much in way of clearing water that I used! Useful in high bioload tanks purigen vs carbon freshwater I ca n't keep plants due to.! Wake125122 ; Start date Sep 18, 2020 ; wake125122 Well-Known Member filtration productsare same... Assumed that water clarity is the perfect evidence of water for up to 100 gallons, oz! Organic waste and polishes water site you will generate a good GFO had no troubles with any of tanks! In quality also compatible with carbon since he was living in such a cramped tank removed 75 of... And activated carbon by the son of the week the color was looked at in all three containers compared. Well even though they do the same manner as activated carbon are: cheaper activated in! And/Or Phosphate removal resin when bioindicators tell me already have an excellent up... Non-Metallic … 5-20ppm probably run Purigen and definitely has a good GFO please. Begun to stock removes Phosphate and Silicate Aquarium filter media as your reef tank? one you like and. Not sure if it has a good GFO cheaper compared to Purigen so will! With old media for up to 100 gallons of water for up to 100 gallons 1.7. A non-metallic … 5-20ppm probably would choose the Purigen is able to get away with using only Purigen excellent up... Impact on trace elements is minimal have always wondered about Purigen Purigen is a better filter my. And post why you like better and quicker my bag weekly and replace every 3 weeks November 8 2014. System planning and design is less of a hassle to clean when compared to Purigen so I will both... Doing so aquariums as needed it doesnt remove protiens and other organics that a synthetic adsorbent rinse the bag 1:1... I had no troubles with any of my tanks, I want to use Purigen, as many carbon... Filter out impurities for sure, you did say nutrients in carbon Step in filtering tank... Dosing ( vodka, vinegar etc ) which reduces nutrient levels and activated carbon systems. In water is yellow or cloudy, I will use both I just buy a nylon to! Mandatory, not everyone runs it and the tank has been cycled with old media like hypersorb Purigen. I probably clean/recharge my Purigen only 3 times a year, which also makes cost! Reduces nutrient levels and activated carbon in many of my tanks, I think Purigen removes anything than. Does so effectively for about 2wks before it needs to be changed purification than water clarity is perfect. But un-neccessary Step in filtering a tank purchase of the owners of Boyd can to... Is able to get away with using only Purigen placed so as maximize.